2021 Postseason All-America Prospect Teams

With the College Baseball World Series in full force in Omaha, it’s a great time to acknowledge the best players in the nation with the first ever selection of College Baseball Nation's Postseason All-America Prospect Teams. As the name suggests, selection to both squads is more contingent on a player’s long-term potential and how he projects as a pro prospect than on merely statistical performance in college baseball. However, there will certainly be a strong correlation between the latter and a player’s appearance in this article.


As the 2021 season progressed, MLB executives and scouts frequently lamented the lower talent level in this year’s draft class relative to prior ones. This shortfall is evident by the fact that 13 of the 30 players selected to both teams are draft eligible in 2022, a draft which is already forecast as one of the strongest in recent memory. And if the high percentage of 2022 draft eligible players on this list isn’t enough to make you salivate at the plethora of talent available next July, consider that most of the “near misses” for this list—Logan Tanner, Dylan Beavers, Hunter Barco, and Connor Prielipp—are draft eligible in 2022 as well.

1st Team


Catcher

Henry Davis (2021 draft eligible), RHH, Louisville—From the first pitch of the season until the last, Davis was easily the best college position player. He consistently barreled the best arms to the tune of a 1.145 OPS while posting a stellar 31/24 BB/K ratio. He also caught 46 percent of would-be base stealers and allowed just three passed balls—a stark improvement over the six passed balls Davis permitted in just 14 games in 2020. It should come as no surprise that Davis is on the Pirates’ shortlist to go 1-01 in next month’s MLB Draft.


First Base

JT Schwartz (2021), LHH, UCLA—Whether it was in the West Coast League, the Northwoods League, or the Pac-12, Schwartz has continuously exhibited his hitting prowess as a collegian. After missing the first several weeks of UCLA’s season with an injury, Schwartz proceeded to hit nearly .400 with an equally sparkling 37/28 BB/K ratio. Persistent questions about his power will likely prompt a fall out of Day 1.


Second Base

Jace Jung (2022), LHH, Texas Tech—Patience is a virtue and many MLB teams are chomping at the bit for the opportunity to select Jung next July. Jung has a turbo-charged swing capable of hitting missiles to all fields, and his discerning eye will keep his OBP propped up as a pro. Jung shifted to 2B from the hot corner when he got to Lubbock, and he’s made steady progress there over the past two years. Jung’s brother Josh was the Rangers’ 1st round pick in the 2019 draft.

Shortstop

Matt McLain (2021), RHH, UCLA—McLain, an unsigned 1st rounder from the 2018 draft, had an uneven season, battling through a slow start then a thumb injury. However, he caught fire after his return and reaffirmed his status as the top college SS in the draft. McLain has garnered comps to Michael Young, David Fletcher, and Brian Dozier, and it’s certainly possible that he’ll eventually shift across the keystone to 2B.


Third Base

Peyton Graham (2022), RHH, Oklahoma—Though Graham’s 2021 stats aren’t on a par with those from the abbreviated 2020 campaign, he’s still an uber-athletic third sacker with a high ceiling on both sides of the ball.


Outfield

Colton Cowser (2021), LHH, Sam Houston—Cowser’s smooth left-handed stroke, burgeoning power, and ability to stick in CF will make him the first Bearkat to go off the board in the 1st round since Glenn Wilson went 18th overall in 1980.


Jud Fabian (2021), RHH, Florida—Fabian is easily the most divisive player in this draft class. Despite a paltry .249 average and 29.4 percent K-rate, Fabian’s easy power, relative youth, and excellent defense in CF will cause a team to bite in the back half of the 1st round.


Sal Frelick (2021), LHH, Boston College—In the age of gorilla ball and three true outcomes offense, Frelick is a refreshing throwback. While he did slug .559 for the Eagles, he struck out in just 12 percent of his PAs and consistently showed the ability to square up good pitching. A center fielder at BC, some teams are interested in Frelick as an offensive-minded second baseman in the upcoming draft.

Designated Hitter

Ethan Wilson (2021), LHH, South Alabama—Wilson had an unorthodox season. He was plagued by an ankle sprain in the early going, which robbed him of his well-chronicled power, yet came on down the stretch. The most impressive take-away from Wilson’s 2021 campaign was his ability to make contact, as evidenced by his outstanding 8.3 percent K-rate. His lower power output notwithstanding, Wilson will not make it out of the supplemental round.


Starting Pitching

Jack Leiter (2021), RHP, Vanderbilt—Although Leiter was second fiddle to Kumar Rocker at the start of the season, he quickly overtook his rotation mate and established himself as the best college righthander in years. In a season full of jaw-dropping moments, Leiter’s tour de force was clearly his 20-inning no-hit streak against SEC stalwarts South Carolina, Missouri, and LSU.


Kumar Rocker (2021), RHP, Vanderbilt—On scouts’ radar since he was a high school underclassman, Rocker did not disappoint during his time in Nashville. Whether it was his 19-K no-hitter vs Duke in the 2019 Super Regionals or his weekly greatness this year, Rocker, with the help of his atomic slider and mid-90’s cheddar, will join Leiter as the best 1-2 pitching tandem in Commodores history and a top-10 draft pick next month.


Ty Madden (2021), RHP, Texas—While Madden defies the current pitching convention of low release height and high spin rate/efficiency on his fastball to combat today’s launch angle-oriented offensive game, his size, command, velocity, and prime secondary offerings (including a wipeout slider) have made him into one of the nation’s most complete pitchers.


Sam Bachman (2021), RHP, Miami (OH)—The darling of analytical departments across MLB, Bachman’s elite heater/slider combo and promising changeup could enable him to sneak into the top-10 on July 11th. That said, some teams have reservations about Bachman’s long-term health.


Ryan Cusick (2021), RHP, Wake Forest—Cusick, a 6-06/235 man child, has a heater that regularly touches the century mark, a plus curveball, and improved changeup. He still needs to cl